Complex PTSD (complex post-traumatic stress disorder) is not only about memories of a traumatic event. It can affect the way we regulate our emotions, the way we see ourselves, and the way we form relationships with others.

A child who grows up with abuse, neglect, unpredictable reactions, emotional unavailability or other repeated experiences of fear, rejection or insecurity does not only learn to fear a specific event. They learn, often without realising it, something much broader:

“If I need someone, I may be let down.”

“If I let go, I may get hurt.”

“Close relationships may not be safe.”

And so, years later, trauma may appear not only as memories, nightmares or hypervigilance, but as a particular way of relating.

Research has begun to shed light on exactly this pathway. In clinical samples of people with a history of childhood trauma, two relational dimensions appear to be particularly significant: fear of abandonment and fear of closeness (Van Dijke, Hopman & Ford, 2018).

When the relationship becomes part of the trauma

Complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD) includes the core symptoms of PTSD — intense and unwanted memories of the traumatic event, avoidance, and a persistent sense of threat — along with a second group of difficulties known as disturbances in self-organisation.

These include difficulty regulating emotions, a negative self-image, and persistent difficulties in relationships (Karatzias et al., 2022). This is particularly significant when the trauma has taken place within close relationships.

For a child, the person they depend on for safety and survival may at the same time be the person from whom they experience fear, insecurity, rejection or threat. The child cannot simply leave the relationship. They cannot say, “This person isn’t good for me, they frighten me, I’ll find someone else.” The relationship is essential to their life.

And so a deep, paradoxical feeling may develop:

“I need other people in order to feel safe, but closeness with them may not be safe.”

This paradox can follow a person into their adult relationships.

Fear of abandonment: “Don’t leave”

For a child, the relationship with those who care for them is not simply an emotional relationship. It is their main source of safety and emotional regulation. When early relationships have been marked by inconsistency, unpredictable availability, separations or repeated rejection, the child cannot easily form the expectation that “when I need them, they will be there”.

Instead, they may develop a sense that relationships are fragile and uncertain. The other person moving away then does not simply mean that they are unavailable right now; it may activate something far more threatening: “I might lose them, and I don’t know whether they will ever come back.”

In an adult relationship, this may show up as an intense sensitivity to signs of distance.

A message that goes unanswered.

A change in tone of voice.

An evening when a partner wants to be alone.

A small disagreement.

For someone who has learned that a relationship can suddenly be lost, these are not always simply events. They may become signs of impending abandonment.

“Something has changed.”

“They’re bored of me.”

“They’re going to leave.”

“I did something wrong.”

And then there may be an intense need for reassurance, difficulty tolerating distance, hypervigilance towards the other person’s mood, or an effort to maintain the connection at any cost.

This is not necessarily an “excessive need for love”, but the activation of a very automatic way of responding to the possibility of losing the relationship. A child does not yet have the developmental capacity to manage this threat alone. They depend on the adult to soothe and reassure them, so that they can feel safe enough to cope with their emotions. The loss of the relationship can therefore be an overwhelming feeling.

This is the same system we often see activated in adults who live with this kind of abandonment pattern. It is as if that old childhood experience is reactivated — the one in which losing the relationship meant the collapse of their world. As if there is not yet, within them, a stable enough sense of safety that can hold these feelings without the other person having to become the only source of reassurance.

Fear of closeness: “Don’t come too close”

There is, however, another side.

Not the fear that the other person will leave, but the fear that they will come too close.

The study by Van Dijke and colleagues treats fear of closeness as an expression of relational avoidance. In their clinical study, this fear, together with fear of abandonment, was found to mediate — alongside other processes — the relationship between childhood trauma and symptoms of complex post-traumatic stress (Van Dijke, Hopman & Ford, 2018).

From the outside, fear of closeness may look very different.

A person may want a relationship, but when it starts to become truly close, they may feel the need to pull away.

They may want to be loved, but find it difficult when someone gets to know them more deeply.

They may seek connection and at the same time feel suffocated by intimacy.

They may feel comfortable as long as the relationship stays at a safe distance, and struggle when vulnerability, dependence, need or deeper emotional exposure appear.

And so something may happen that often causes confusion: a person pulls away at the very moment they get what they supposedly wanted.

Not because they do not want the relationship.

But because closeness may have become linked, at a deeper level, with danger.

“I want you here, but not so close”

The two fears are not necessarily opposites.

They can coexist.

“I’m afraid you’ll leave me.”

and at the same time:

“I’m afraid of what will happen if I let you come really close to me.”

This creates a particularly difficult relational cycle.

A person may intensely seek out the other when they feel distance. But when the other responds and comes closer, they may feel vulnerable, exposed or trapped, and pull away.

And when the other person then moves away in response, the original fear of abandonment is confirmed:

“I knew it. They’re leaving.”

In this way, fear of abandonment may intensify the need for connection, while fear of closeness may activate the need for distance.

And the relationship becomes a space in which the person oscillates between:

“Come closer.”

and

“Don’t come so close.”

Trauma can change what closeness means

In a relationship that has been experienced as safe, closeness may be associated with safety, trust, acceptance and reciprocity.

For someone who has learned that important relationships can be a source of danger, the same experience may mean vulnerability, loss of control, exposure, and the possibility of rejection or hurt.

Closeness, then, is not experienced only as “how close I am to someone”.

It becomes a way in which the person assesses, often automatically, whether a relationship is safe or threatening.

This helps us understand why avoiding relationships is not always simply a lack of interest. It may be an attempt at protection.

It is not only about “what happened”

This also changes the way we can understand childhood trauma.

The question is not only:

“What happened to you?”

It is also:

“What did you learn about relationships from what happened to you?”

Did you learn that people leave?
That you have to keep them close so as not to lose them?
That if you show a need, you will be disappointed?
That if you let yourself rely on someone, you may get hurt?
That love comes with unpredictable behaviour?
That safety can suddenly disappear?

These learned expectations can become part of the inner models through which a person approaches future relationships.

This is why complex trauma is not only about the past. It is about the way the past may continue to organise the present, and our present relationships.

Why the treatment of complex trauma is relational work

If trauma has affected the way a person relates, then therapy cannot be limited to processing individual memories and experiences.

It needs to become a space in which the person can gradually experience something different.

A relationship in which closeness does not lead to intrusion.

Disagreement does not lead to abandonment.

Need does not provoke shame.

Vulnerability is not punished.

Distance can exist without meaning loss.

And connection can exist without meaning a loss of self.

This does not mean that the therapist becomes a “corrective parental figure”, nor that the therapeutic relationship heals trauma on its own. It means that the therapeutic relationship itself becomes an important field in which relational expectations, fears and the protective strategies that have developed can be observed and worked through.

Karatzias and colleagues highlight the importance of a safe therapeutic relationship in the treatment of CPTSD, particularly where there are difficulties with trust, emotional regulation and closeness. A therapeutic relationship that is experienced as safe can become an important space in which these patterns can be recognised, expressed and processed.

In psychotherapy, we are not simply trying to eliminate a “problematic behaviour”.

We are trying to understand which need, which fear, and which old way of relating lie behind it.

The relationship as a place where something different can be written

Childhood trauma may continue to operate through the way we expect relationships to work.

And so therapy is not only a return to the past.

It is also the opportunity to notice, in the present, what happens when someone comes closer.

What happens when they move away.

What happens when we need someone.

What happens when someone needs us.

What happens when we trust.

And, little by little, to discover that intimacy does not have to mean danger, and distance does not have to mean abandonment.

The treatment of relational trauma is about learning, through new relational experiences, that what was once dangerous is not necessarily dangerous in the relationships we have today.

References

  • Karatzias, T., Shevlin, M., Ford, J. D., Fyvie, C., Grandison, G., Hyland, P., & Cloitre, M. (2022). Childhood trauma, attachment orientation, and complex PTSD (CPTSD) symptoms in a clinical sample: Implications for treatment. Development and Psychopathology, 34(3), 1192–1197. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954579420001509
  • Van Dijke, A., Hopman, J. A. B., & Ford, J. D. (2018). Childhood trauma, attachment style, and dysfunctional emotion regulation: An additive and mediating model of PTSD and CPTSD symptoms. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 9(1), 1486063. https://doi.org/10.1080/20008198.2018.1486063