There are moments in life when we may find ourselves wondering: “Who am I, really? What do I want? What do I enjoy? What do I want my life to be like?”

We may have spent years learning to respond to other people’s needs — to be “good girls”, good partners, good mothers, successful professionals, always-available friends. We may know very well what others need, and yet find it hard to answer a much simpler question:

“What do I need?”

And so a lack of self-confidence does not always look like insecurity or difficulty in achieving things. It may look like over-effort, perfectionism, difficulty saying “no”, a need for reassurance, or constant doubt about our choices. And beneath all of this there is often tiredness, loneliness, heaviness, sadness, a sense of dissatisfaction — a feeling that we may be living a life that does not feel entirely our own.

Perhaps, then, the question is not only “How can I become more self-confident?”, but rather: “How can I find my way back into contact with myself?”

Self-confidence is not about believing I can do everything

We often talk about self-confidence as if it were a trait we either have or do not have. As if some people were born sure of themselves, while others need to “work on themselves” to become that way.

The reality is more complex.

Self-confidence does not mean that I am not afraid, that I do not doubt, or that I do not make mistakes. It does not mean believing that I am beautiful, clever, capable, superior or better than others.

Rather, it means something much deeper: being able to trust myself even when I am not certain of the outcome.

Being able to say:
“I don’t know whether I’ll manage, but I will be able to support myself.”

This sense of trust is different from the need to always be strong, right, positive, or in the right. It also includes the possibility of recognising my limits, making mistakes, changing my mind and asking for help.

When we have learned to see ourselves through other people’s eyes

The image we have of ourselves is not created in a vacuum.

From very early on, we learn who we are through our relationships. Through the way the people who care for us look at us, listen to us, recognise us or reject us.

A child who feels there is room for their feelings, their needs and their individuality may gradually develop the sense that:
“What I feel matters. I am worthy.”

By contrast, when acceptance seems to depend on behaviour, performance or compliance, a child may learn:
“I am worth something when I succeed.”
“I am loved when I don’t make things difficult for others, or when I have no needs.”
“I have to be good for people to want me.”
“I have to be liked in order to be worthy.”

Over time, these experiences become the inner voices that guide us in our relationships.

In Gestalt psychotherapy we speak of introjection: “messages” and “shoulds” that we once absorbed without being able to question them, or to keep only what suited us. Because back then, as children, we needed the people around us, and adopting these messages was a way of staying close to them, of feeling safe and accepted, and so of surviving.

Winnicott described something related through the concept of the false self. When a child needs to adapt constantly to the needs and moods of others, they may develop a self that is accommodating and “good”, a self that does not cause difficulties for anyone. This self is not a lie. It is an adaptive solution that once protected us. Over time, however, it may cover our spontaneous feelings, needs and desires so thoroughly that we no longer remember what it is like to feel them.

And then perhaps we no longer need anyone else to judge us. We have learned to do it ourselves.

Low self-confidence may be hiding behind perfectionism

Sometimes low self-confidence does not look like insecurity at all.

It may look like perfectionism.

“I have to do it perfectly.”
“I’m not allowed to make a mistake.”
“If I fail, I’ll prove that I’m not enough.”

And when something does not go the way we wanted, the inner voice can become very harsh: “I’m worthless. I knew I wasn’t good enough. Now they’ll see who I really am.” A small mistake may bring shame, disappointment and fear of rejection, as if it were not only what we did that was being judged, but our entire existence.

Behind the need to do everything right, there may be a deeper fear: that without success, appearance, performance or other people’s approval, we are not allowed to exist.

Perhaps, at one time, perfectionism was a way of feeling safe. If I do everything right, they won’t judge or reject me. If I don’t make mistakes, I won’t disappoint anyone. If I am flawless, I will be loved and wanted. The price, however, is constant vigilance and the burden of continually proving my competence — something that does not ease when we rest physically or take time off work.

This is why self-confidence is not necessarily built by trying to become “better”.

It is built by learning that we do not need to be perfect in order to be worthy of love and acceptance.

“How do I find myself?”

The phrase “finding myself” can sound as if there were an authentic self somewhere, waiting to be discovered beneath the layers of “shoulds” we have put on.

In reality, our relationship with ourselves is continually being shaped and transformed.

We do not simply find ourselves.
We get to know ourselves. We listen to ourselves. We shape ourselves again and again, because the self is not a static entity but a living process that transforms in line with our developmental needs.

This can begin with very small questions.

What do I enjoy?
What do I do because I want to, and what do I do because I’m afraid of disappointing someone?
When do I feel most like myself?
Who can I be spontaneous with?
When do I say “yes” when inside I want to say “no”?
What do I put up with because I’m afraid of what will happen if I set a boundary?
What do I long for but find it hard to ask for?

These questions are not meant to give us quick answers. They are meant to help us turn our attention inwards again.

And often the answers do not come first from our thoughts, but from our body. What happens inside me when I say “yes” but want to say “no”? Does my stomach tighten? Does my breathing become short and shallow? Do I feel a weight on my shoulders, or a sense of relief when something is cancelled? The body often knows what we need before we have had time to think about it.

Gestalt psychotherapy places great importance on this embodied awareness in the here and now. Because very often, at the moment something is happening, our mind is elsewhere and we act mechanically, in the way we think we “should”, without it really being our own choice. When we can pause for a moment with what we are feeling in that moment, a small space opens up between “I should” and “I want”.

Our self may become visible in our choices

Sometimes we wait to feel certain first, and only then make a choice.

But the reverse may also be true.

Trust in ourselves is built when we begin to make small decisions that genuinely fit who we are.

Choosing what we want to eat.
Wearing something because we like it, and not because we think it will flatter us more in other people’s eyes.
Turning down an invitation when we are tired.
Expressing a different opinion.
Asking for what we need.
Setting boundaries in a relationship that hurts us.
Allowing ourselves to try something new without knowing whether it will work.

Each time we listen to one of our own needs and give it room, we send ourselves a message:
“I hear you, and it’s okay to try.”

And this experience may matter far more than any positive affirmation in front of the mirror.

Why might we be afraid to be ourselves?

If contact with ourselves is something we long for, why is it so difficult?

Perhaps because listening to what I want means that I will also have to choose. And every choice has a price. I may disappoint someone. I may get it wrong. I may lose something, or someone.

Irvin Yalom describes freedom and responsibility as one of the basic existential givens of our lives: to a large extent, we are the authors of our own lives. This may sound liberating, but it can also be frightening. Because if there is no one else who knows what is right for me, then the responsibility for my life is mine.

Living according to other people’s “shoulds” may therefore also be a way of protecting ourselves from the anxiety of this freedom, and of feeling safe. If I do what is expected of me, at least I won’t be the one responsible if something goes wrong.

Kierkegaard wrote, almost two centuries ago, that the most common form of despair is not wanting to be oneself. Perhaps not because we do not want to, but because at some point we learned that it was dangerous.

Yet not being ourselves also has a price, perhaps a quieter one: a life that may look right from the outside, but that emotionally does not feel like our own.

Self-confidence needs relationship

The self cannot create itself on its own. The philosopher Martin Buber, whose thinking deeply influenced Gestalt psychotherapy, wrote that whoever lives without genuine encounter with another loses something of their humanity. For Buber, “a person becomes I through the Thou”. The self does not exist before the relationship; it is born within the encounter. This is why every relationship holds the possibility of reinventing myself, of creating myself anew. This opens up remarkable possibilities for who we might become. Seeing the self as something dynamic stands in sharp contrast to the “truths” many of us grew up with: “You’re just like your father” or “your mother”, or “People don’t change”.

We need relationships in which we can exist without constantly having to prove our worth.

A relationship in which we can say “I disagree” without fearing that we will lose the other person, because our existence and our acceptance are not conditional.
A relationship in which we can say “I need help” without feeling weak.
A relationship in which we can show a side of ourselves that is not perfect, and still be accepted.

This is why difficulty with self-confidence is often not only an “inner” difficulty. It is, more than anything, a sign of the way we have learned to exist within our relationships.

When I am very afraid of rejection, I may adapt.
When I am afraid of abandonment, I may find it hard to set boundaries.
When I have learned that I must take care of others, I may have lost touch with what I myself need.

Therapeutic work, then, is not about “thinking more positively”. It is about exploring the way I have learned to relate to myself and to others.

And this exploration does not happen through words alone. Often, whatever we struggle with in our relationships outside also appears within the therapeutic relationship. I may try to be “good” there too, not to make things difficult for my therapist, to say what I think she wants to hear. When this can be spoken about and given room, the therapeutic relationship becomes a place where we can try something new: to disagree, to ask, to show a more vulnerable, imperfect side of ourselves — and to remain in contact.

From “I am enough” to “I am me”

There is an important difference between trying to convince myself that I am enough and being able to genuinely inhabit myself.

The first can become yet another demand:
“I should love myself.”
“I should be self-confident.”
“I should be strong.”

The second is quieter.

It is the capacity to recognise:
“I like this.”
“This doesn’t work for me.”
“Here, I’m afraid.”
“Here, I’m angry.”
“I need this.”
“Here, I made a mistake.”
“I want this.”

And to be able to stay in contact with myself even when someone else disagrees.

Arnold Beisser, in his paradoxical theory of change, proposed that change occurs when a person becomes what they are, not when they try to become what they are not. In practice, this means that the more I push myself to become more confident, stronger, more “enough”, the more I keep telling myself that the way I am is not okay, and that I must become something other than what I am and feel right now. Whereas when I can recognise and accept that here I am afraid, or here I doubt, something may begin to soften, and I may begin to feel accepted. And from this, a more stable belief in myself may emerge — one that does not need to be constantly proven.

And so self-confidence comes to resemble not so much the belief that “I am enough”, but the experience that “I can be me”.

And perhaps finding ourselves does not mean discovering who we “should” be.

But beginning, little by little, to listen to who we already are.

References

  • Beisser, A. (1970). The paradoxical theory of change. In J. Fagan & I. L. Shepherd (Eds.), Gestalt therapy now (pp. 77–80). Science and Behavior Books.
  • Buber, M. (1970). I and thou (W. Kaufmann, Trans.). Charles Scribner’s Sons. (Original work published 1923)
  • Kierkegaard, S. (1980). The sickness unto death (H. V. Hong & E. H. Hong, Trans.). Princeton University Press. (Original work published 1849)
  • Perls, F., Hefferline, R. F., & Goodman, P. (1951). Gestalt therapy: Excitement and growth in the human personality. Julian Press.
  • Winnicott, D. W. (1965). Ego distortion in terms of true and false self. In The maturational processes and the facilitating environment (pp. 140–152). Hogarth Press. (Original work published 1960)
  • Yalom, I. D. (1980). Existential psychotherapy. Basic Books.