Very often, when we think, we become one with our thoughts. We automatically adopt whatever words take shape in our heads as self-evident truth. We tell ourselves, “I think it, so what I think must be true.” Often, however, this is a misconception. Our thoughts express various inner processes — fears, anxieties, insecurities — which are frequently phrased as questions or concerns: “They don’t want me, so I’m probably not worth much”, “They don’t listen to me, so I’m probably not important”.

There is a capacity that allows us to separate our thinking from the self that does the thinking — the person from the thoughts. We are not our thoughts, and our thoughts are not us. In order to create this space between them, we use a capacity that is not so much about what we think, but about being able to observe how we think. Not only to feel, but to be able to recognise what is happening inside us and how we are feeling.

Not simply to react to a situation, but to be able to ask ourselves: “What is happening inside me right now? Why am I seeing it this way? What makes me so sure that this is the only truth? What makes me assume that what I feel is necessarily the same as what the other person may be feeling?” Or: “What makes me feel or believe that what I am thinking is a prediction of the future?”

This capacity is called metacognition, and it involves awareness and observation of our own thoughts.

Put simply, it is the ability to think about how we think.

Being afraid that I will not reach my goal and having thoughts about it is one thing; noticing that I am having this thought is another. The first involves identifying myself with what I fear and think. The second recognises that it is simply a thought, and that many different thoughts, interpretations and possibilities may exist alongside it.

From “I think” to “I notice that I am thinking”

When someone thinks “They don’t like me”, they may experience this thought as reality. Thought and reality seem to merge within them.

Metacognition creates a small but important distance:

“I notice that I am thinking they don’t like me.”

The difference may seem small, but psychologically it is very significant. In the first case, the person is inside the thought. In the second, they can see it from a different position — not from the position of someone who feels disliked, but from the position of someone observing that experience. In this way, they have more options for thinking and acting, rather than sinking into the position of the person who is not liked.

When we can observe a thought, we begin to have more options in relation to it. We can examine it, question it, look for other interpretations, or even decide that we do not need to adopt it.

The thought then stops being automatically treated as objective reality, and becomes something we can observe.

This capacity can be practised and cultivated. Like many things in our lives and in the way we function, it develops through growth and practice. A great deal of psychological distress is linked to the absence of this space between what is happening inside us and the way we react.

Someone feels rejected and withdraws. Someone else fears abandonment and tries to control the relationship. Someone gets angry and attacks. Someone else feels ashamed and hides.

The reaction may be so automatic that there is no time for the question:

“What is happening to me right now?”

Metacognition creates precisely this space. A space between a feeling and identifying with it; between a thought and a belief.

In this way, we can feel and think, and at the same time be aware that we are doing so.

We can say:

“I feel afraid, but that doesn’t necessarily mean there is danger.”

“I feel rejected, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they are rejecting me.”

“I feel the need to leave, but perhaps this need is connected to something I learned to do when I’m afraid.”

This differentiation is an important form of psychological freedom and possibility.

Metacognition in psychotherapy

In a sense, psychotherapy is a process of cultivating this capacity.

In therapy, we do not only explore what a person thinks. Together, we observe how they think, how they learned to think this way, what assumptions they make about themselves and others, how they perceive their emotions, and how past experiences influence what is happening now.

For example, a client might say: “When he doesn’t reply, I start to worry and feel that he’s lost interest.”

Therapeutic exploration may gradually shift this certainty towards a different thought: “When he doesn’t reply, I notice that the thought that he’s lost interest comes immediately. But could this be about something of my own? Could there be other possible explanations? Could this interpretation appear so quickly because it is based on something I know from my past?”

This is not simply a change of thought. It is a shift in the relationship we have with our thoughts.

When a thought stops being absolute truth

One characteristic of psychological pain is often rigidity. One interpretation becomes the only possible interpretation. A feeling becomes proof. An old experience becomes a prediction of the future.

“Since I’m afraid, something bad will happen.”

“Since I feel inadequate, it means I am inadequate.”

“Since he pulled away, it means I’m not worth anything.”

Metacognition does not necessarily say that these thoughts are wrong. It allows us to examine the process that led to a thought, an attitude or a situation in the present, rather than treating the thought as a given.

And this matters a great deal for mental health, because it allows us to develop greater psychological flexibility.

Metacognition is not overthinking

A person may spend hours thinking: “Why did I say that? What did they mean? Did they take it the wrong way? What could I have said differently? Why do I feel like this?” — without actually gaining any greater awareness.

Overthinking often traps us more deeply inside our thoughts. Metacognition, by contrast, creates distance from them, and space.

Perhaps the difference lies here:

Overthinking keeps asking “why?” in search of certainty. Metacognition helps us notice that we are searching for certainty, or safety, through our thoughts.

“I notice that I am desperately trying to work out what the other person is thinking, because I find it hard to bear uncertainty or to cope with rejection.”

This involves a different level of awareness.

Metacognition and our relationship with ourselves

The ability to observe our inner world can also change the relationship we have with ourselves.

When I can see that a thought is a thought, a feeling is a feeling, and an old belief is a belief shaped by my experience, then my self becomes something more than the content of my thoughts and feelings.

I am not the thought “I’m not worthy”.

I am not the fear or anxiety I feel.

I am not my shame.

I am the person who can notice that all of these, and many other things, exist within me.

This distance is not a distancing from the self. On the contrary, it is a deeper and broader way of getting to know it.

And in our relationships

Metacognition is not only about our inner life. It also matters greatly for our relationships.

When we can observe our own interpretation of a situation, we become more able to recognise that the other person also has their own inner world, different from ours.

“I experienced it as rejection. But that doesn’t mean the other person intended to reject me.”

This creates room for curiosity instead of certainty.

And perhaps this is where metacognition meets one of the most important functions of psychotherapy: the capacity to stay in contact with our own experience without losing awareness that the other person is having a different experience.

From automatic reaction to choice

Mental health does not mean that we will stop feeling afraid, angry, jealous or ashamed, or that we will stop having negative thoughts.

It means, rather, that we can gradually develop greater flexibility in relation to all of these.

To feel without being overwhelmed.

To think without adopting every thought as a given.

To recognise our needs without demanding that others meet them in one particular way.

To be able to say:

“This is one of the thoughts or feelings that exist within me. But it doesn’t have to automatically determine what I do.”

The value of metacognition lies in the fact that it allows us not to be entirely identified with what we think.

And perhaps this is one of the most important gifts of psychotherapy: not a mind that never struggles, but a mind that can observe its struggle, understand it, and create, within it, a little more room for choice.

Because, in the end, psychological freedom does not lie in controlling everything that happens inside us.

It lies in being able to observe it without having to become one with it each time — without having to respond to every thought and every feeling as though it were “the truth”.