There are days when we feel we barely have time to think. There is tension in the body, difficulty concentrating, a knot in the stomach, irritability, or a sense of being constantly on alert.

We usually associate this state with anxiety.

Sometimes, however, what we are experiencing is more like stress. At other times it is anxiety. And quite often, the two exist together.

The distinction is not simply a matter of terminology. It may help us understand more clearly what is happening inside us and, above all, what we need in that particular moment.

Stress: when body and mind are in a state of constant alertness

Stress is usually linked to a demand, a change or a situation that we perceive as difficult or threatening. It may be a demanding work environment, financial difficulty, a conflict, a separation, a major life change, or a period of caring for someone we love.

It can even arise from something that is, in theory, positive: moving house, a new job, the birth of a child, a wedding.

The body does not evaluate an experience only as “good” or “bad”.

It registers that it is being called upon to adapt and to manage demands and deadlines, and to invest a great deal of energy and thought in different areas.

The American Psychological Association describes stress as the physical or psychological response to internal or external stressors. It may be accompanied by physical and emotional reactions such as muscle tension, fatigue, difficulty sleeping, irritability, digestive discomfort and difficulty concentrating.

There is a level of activation in the body that mobilises us to respond to something demanding that may be happening. Muscles may become more tense, the heart may beat faster, breathing may become quicker and shallower, and sweating may increase.

At the same time, the brain is in a state of greater readiness: our attention may sharpen, allowing us to notice smaller details that often go unnoticed and to react more quickly to what is happening around us. Even digestion may temporarily take second place, as the body directs more resources towards what it considers necessary for an immediate response.

The problem begins when this demand persists for a long period and the body is operating at the edge of its capacity to respond, or when there is not enough time for recovery — which are, in other words, the conditions that usually lead to burnout.

Anxiety: when the sense of threat continues even when there is nothing specific in front of us

In the body, anxiety is quite similar to stress. We may experience a racing heart, tension, difficulty sleeping, fatigue, difficulty concentrating, or a more general sense of unease.

The important difference often lies in where our attention is directed.

With stress, there is usually an identifiable stressor: “I have a difficult job”, “I’m going through a hard period of processing a separation”, “There’s a problem I need to solve”, “We have a baby who needs a lot of care and attention”.

With anxiety, by contrast, the worry continues even when the immediate source of stress has gone, or when there is nothing specific connected to it. Our thinking often shifts towards something general, or towards the future:

What if something happens?
What if I don’t manage?
What if someone I love gets ill?
What if I make a mistake?
What if I lose control?

So there may be no immediate problem in front of us, and yet the body may continue to behave as though it needs to protect itself from something that is about to happen. This is how the American Psychological Association distinguishes anxiety from stress: anxiety is characterised by persistent and excessive worry that does not necessarily subside once the stressor has been removed.

Not all anxiety is a disorder, or pathological

Anxiety is also a natural human response. It can function as an inner alarm system, alerting us that something needs our attention or our energy. Anxiety-provoking and stressful situations will always arise; life is not easy, and very often we need to build and pursue things on our own and from scratch.

The question, then, is not only “How do I get rid of anxiety?”

But also:

“What is this anxiety trying to tell me?”

When stress turns into anxiety

Prolonged stress can leave the nervous system in a state of constant readiness. When, for a long time, we have to keep responding to demands without having the chance to recover, we may begin to feel that something bad is always about to happen and that we need to stay on guard. Difficulties with sleep may follow, along with difficulty resting, feeling joy, or taking pleasure in things. It is as if we were soldiers ready for battle in a field where a bomb could go off at any moment, and we must stay watchful.

“I have a problem to deal with” may gradually turn into:

“I have to be constantly ready for the next problem.”

And then the original external difficulty may be over, while the inner alertness, waiting for the next difficulty, remains.

This is why a person may sometimes say:

“I don’t have any particular problem any more. Why do I still feel so anxious?”

Perhaps because the body and the psyche have not yet had time to register that the threat has passed — and because we are not giving the body enough of what it needs to move out of this state of continuous alert. Important functions such as eating, sleeping and connecting with other people may be carried out in a compulsive or hurried way, and may no longer bring us satisfaction.

An existential perspective: not all anxiety is pathological

Existential psychotherapy adds a different dimension to this discussion.

There is a kind of anxiety that does not come from a specific everyday difficulty, but from human existence itself.

Yalom describes four basic existential realities that we cannot avoid: death, freedom, existential isolation and the search for meaning. Awareness of these can give rise to existential anxiety.

There is, for example, a difference between:

“I’m anxious because I have an important presentation tomorrow”

and:

“I’m anxious because I’m realising that I cannot fully control what will happen.”

The second is not necessarily something that can be “solved”.

We cannot guarantee that we will never lose someone we love. We cannot know with certainty what will happen in the future. We cannot avoid all choices and their consequences. And we cannot eliminate uncertainty from human life.

Existential psychotherapy, then, does not treat every anxiety as an enemy to be defeated.

Sometimes anxiety is our point of contact with expressions of these deeper existential conditions, hidden within the everyday manifestations of life. These existential dimensions do not only appear at moments when we are consciously thinking about death, freedom, isolation or meaning. They may be hidden within very ordinary experiences: anxiety about taking a new professional step; fear about the illness of people we love; dread in the face of adulthood and all that it means; or an overwhelming, frightening pain on coming into contact with loneliness.

The therapeutic work, then, is not about managing never to be afraid, but about being able to live alongside a degree of uncertainty without organising our whole life around avoiding it.

The Gestalt perspective: what is happening here and now?

Instead of immediately trying to avoid anxiety, we can observe how it is showing up in this moment.

How is it affecting my posture or my breathing?

What thought accompanies this sensation?

What am I trying to do, or not do?

Where are my energy and my attention going?

All of these questions aim to sharpen awareness — that is, a deeper contact with how I am in the present moment.

This is particularly important when anxiety appears just before a significant move.

I want to speak, but I hold back.

I want to leave, but I stay.

I want to say “no”, but I smile.

I want to get closer to someone, but I pull away.

I want to change something in my life, but I keep doing the same thing.

Here, anxiety does not need to be treated only as a symptom. It can become information about a process that is under way, allowing us to understand symptoms within the wider field of our life and relationships, rather than as exclusively individual processes.

There may be a need that has not yet found expression, a boundary that has not been spoken, a desire that has not been acknowledged, or a change that is approaching but frightens us.

The question shifts from:

“How do I stop feeling anxious?”

to:

“What is happening in my life right now, and how am I standing in relation to it?”

Our anxiety is not always created and maintained within an isolated individual

As human beings, we exist within relationships.

We may become more anxious when we fear being rejected or judged, when we feel we must meet other people’s expectations, when we find it hard to set boundaries, or when an important relationship becomes uncertain.

So behind:

“I’m afraid they’ll leave me”

there may be something deeper:

“What would it mean for me to lose this relationship?”

And behind:

“I’m afraid of disappointing others”

there may be:

“Who am I when I am not meeting other people’s needs?”

The therapeutic relationship itself can become a space in which these experiences emerge and can be observed as they happen. Research on the psychotherapy relationship has shown that the relationship with the therapist can function as a secure base from which clients can explore difficult experiences (Mallinckrodt, 2010).

So therapy is not only about learning techniques to “calm down”.

It is also about being able to understand what happens to us when we are in relationship with others.

So what do I need: stress management, or an understanding of my anxiety?

If I am going through a period of excessive demands, little rest, a lot of work and constant obligations, then what I may need first of all is relief and a change in circumstances.

Not everything is a psychological problem that we need to solve within ourselves.

Sometimes we need to sleep more, reduce our commitments, set boundaries, ask for help, or step away from a situation that is draining us.

Of course, adult life — especially alongside children, demanding jobs, financial insecurity and the rising cost of living — is full of obligations, of prioritising other people’s needs, of insecurity and ongoing stress. How easy it is for us to recover from stressful situations is a separate discussion, for which there is not enough room here.

Clearly, many stressors would ease if there were a well-structured network of social support and decent, fair working conditions.

So when tension persists even after circumstances have improved, when worry keeps moving from one subject to another, or when the mind is constantly searching for a possible threat, it may be worth exploring the anxiety more deeply.

Some questions that may help us recognise which phase we are in:
What is happening in my life?
What am I trying to cope with?
What am I afraid will happen?
What can I not control?
Which of my needs has no room?
In which relationship do I feel insecure?
Which choice is difficult for me?
What does what is happening mean to me?
And what is life asking of me at this time?

Stress may be telling us: “Something is demanding energy and attention from me.”

Anxiety may be telling us: “I don’t know what will happen, and I’m worried.”

And sometimes, at a deeper level, it may be asking us:

“How do I want to exist in a world I cannot fully control?”

And this is where an important part of psychotherapeutic work lies.

Not in trying to create a life without anxiety, but in being able to develop a different relationship with it: to be able to listen to it without always acting from it; to feel it without being overwhelmed by it; and to keep choosing how we want to live and to be, even when part of life remains uncertain.

References

  • Mallinckrodt, B. (2010). The psychotherapy relationship as attachment: Evidence and implications. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 27(2), 262–269.