“My parents weren’t bad people. I was a difficult child.”

“They were strict, but they did it for my own good.”

“They punished me; they wanted me to be perfect and never make mistakes. So that’s how I learned to be too.”

Phrases like these are often heard in the therapy room. It can be hard for people to stay emotionally with what these sentences contain, because they feel that if they do, they will be blaming their parents — with whom they may have a very good relationship today. And so, not knowing how to hold the contrast between what they lived through as children and what exists now, they may have learned not to linger on the difficult and complicated parts of their past.

We do not need to have experienced physical violence in order to recognise signs of relational trauma. There may have been someone’s silence whenever we made a “mistake”; or sarcasm in front of others; or a repeated threat of “I’ll leave you here and go”; or being made to feel ashamed of something we found difficult.

And alongside this, almost always, the same inner movement: to excuse, to minimise, to take the weight upon ourselves, so that we do not have to place it on someone else.

Why does this happen? Why is it so hard to say, even as adults, that the people who loved us may also have been the people who hurt us?

A child cannot choose to leave the relationship with their parents

A young child has nowhere else to go. The people who care for them are their food, their comfort, their refuge, their source of safety and, quite literally, their survival.

John Bowlby showed that children’s attachment to their parents is a biological system: when a child is frightened, they turn towards those who care for them. But what happens when the fear comes from those very same people? Mary Main and Erik Hesse described this impasse: the parent who frightens the child is at the same time the person the child needs to turn to in order to be soothed. The body says “run away” and “move closer” at the same moment.

Within this impasse, the child cannot do what an adult might do: move away, protect themselves, set boundaries. What they can do is change something inside. They can change the way they perceive what is happening.

When I cannot change the relationship, I change what I feel and perceive, so that I can remain within it.

“Banished knowledge”

Alice Miller devoted almost all of her work to precisely this movement. In The Drama of the Gifted Child, she describes highly sensitive and attentive children who learn to read their parents’ needs and to become what their parents need, leaving their own feelings outside of awareness. Anger, pain and disappointment have no place in the relationship. And whatever has no place in the relationship, the child learns not to feel.

One of her books has a title that anticipates both its content and this reality.

In Banished Knowledge, Miller writes that the abused child does not only suppress their emotions. They also suppress what they sense in their body and perceive with their mind and senses. They ignore what they know, because if they stayed with that knowledge, they would have to bear something unbearable: that they are alone in the face of the very people they depend on — a truth that a child cannot realise and cannot endure.

In For Your Own Good, she shows how entire generations grew up within a logic she called “poisonous pedagogy”: punishment, humiliation and fear were presented as love and care. If I am told that I am being hit because I am loved, then I learn that love hurts. But I also learn something else: not to trust what I feel.

In one of her last books, The Body Never Lies, Miller goes further still. She argues that “honour your father and your mother”, when it becomes an obligation to feel love and gratitude towards people who hurt us, keeps us away from our own truth. The mind may agree with the family’s version of events, but the body keeps its own memory. Remaining blindly loyal to a love that hurts, then, may mean betraying parts of ourselves.

Why it is safer, as children, for the fault to be ours

Miller was not the only one to write about this. As early as 1943, the psychoanalyst Ronald Fairbairn described something he called the “moral defence”. The child prefers to see themselves as bad rather than accept that their parents are bad. Because, as Fairbairn put it, it is better to be a sinner in a world ruled by God than to live in a world ruled by the Devil. In the first world there is still order and hope. In the second, there is nothing to hold on to.

Judith Herman, in Trauma and Recovery, writes that the abused child needs to find a way to preserve a sense of trust and safety in relation to people who are not trustworthy — a sense that is absolutely necessary for their healthy development. The compromise they reach is very often this: if I am bad, then my parents are good. And paradoxically, this also gives the child a certain power: if it is my fault, then I can try to become better. There is something I can do.

Perhaps this is where the roots lie of a shame we may carry for years without knowing where it comes from. It is not only about “I did something wrong”. It is the deeper sense that I am not worthy, that something in my very existence is flawed. This sense may once have been the price we paid for our parents to remain good in our eyes — so that we could stay close to them, feel some degree of safety, and survive.

In the language of Gestalt psychotherapy, we would say that the anger that could not be directed towards the parents was turned inwards. This is what we call retroflection: I turn inwards what I needed to express outwards; I do to myself what I would have wanted to do or say to the other person. Self-criticism, harshness towards ourselves, and difficulty standing up for our own needs may be the continuation of an old solution.

The blindness that protects

The psychologist Jennifer Freyd gave this phenomenon a name that is very helpful: betrayal trauma. It is the trauma caused by people or institutions we depend on for survival. Freyd argues that, in these circumstances, recognising the betrayal may itself be dangerous: if the child sees clearly what is happening, they might pull away or react, and so risk losing the relationship that keeps them alive. This is why she speaks of “betrayal blindness” — the “not knowing and forgetting” that protects the relationship.

The word “betrayal” carries particular weight here. The ancient Greek verb for “to betray”, prodídomi, originally meant “to give beforehand”, but also “to hand over to the enemy” and “to abandon someone at the moment they are in danger”. This is exactly the experience of an abused child: the person who should stand between them and danger becomes the danger. And the child is left alone at the very moment they most needed someone beside them — one of the deepest expressions of relational trauma.

Freyd also observes that awareness of betrayal may come much later, when the person no longer depends on those who hurt them. This is why many people are able to see truths like these only as adults — in their thirties, in their fifties, after a loss, or when they become parents themselves. And then they often feel confused: “Why now? I thought I was over all this.”

Authoritarian parenting is linked to absence

We often say of people who raise their children with great strictness that they are, in a sense, absent from the relationship. They may hide behind phrases such as “I’m doing it for your own good”, “This is how you’ll grow up to be a decent person”, “This is how character is built” — clichés with which generation after generation has been raised, many of whom were themselves mistreated.

Behind these phrases, they often cannot see the child in front of them, or truly relate to them. They see the child’s mistakes rather than their difficulty; what the child did not do rather than how they feel; they see the crying, but not why the child is crying. And so, by making the relationship difficult, they may never really come to know their child. Because they themselves are hiding behind their own rigidity and their own sense of inadequacy — and very often the child becomes the one who is expected to achieve what they themselves could not.

Many of these parents never truly talked with their child in order to understand how it feels to be a small being trying to learn about the world from them. Instead, they learned to impose their own needs on the relationship. Raising and shaping a child means feeling with them and interacting with them — not imposing what I believe to be right while ignoring their needs.

Seeing the truth does not mean ceasing to love, or rejecting, our parents

This is often where the greatest fear lies: that if I see what happened to me, I will lose my parents. Or I will become ungrateful. Or I will have to choose between my truth and my love.

And yet, our experience may be able to hold both. I can love my mother and know that she hurt me. I can understand my father’s history and still not excuse what he did. Understanding our parents’ story does not need to erase our own.

Miller speaks of the need for mourning. To grieve not only what happened, but also what never happened: the parents we needed and did not have, the protection that never came, the childhood that cannot be rewritten. This grief is painful, because it means letting go of the hope that one day they will give us what they owe us. But it can also be liberating. As long as we keep waiting, we remain the child who is waiting to be rescued.

From an existential perspective, Irvin Yalom writes about existential isolation: the realisation that, however much we are loved, no one can live our life for us or save us from it. Perhaps recognising abuse brings us face to face with an early and very harsh version of this isolation. But it also brings us face to face with our freedom and our responsibility: to decide, ourselves, now, what relationship we want to have with our past and with the people who are still in our lives. This might mean setting boundaries in a relationship that hurts us, saying something that was never said, or simply no longer telling ourselves that “it was nothing”.

A witness who sees our pain

Miller wrote that an abused child can endure and process what happened far better when there is at least one person who bears witness to it and shows them, in some way, that it is not their fault. A grandmother, a teacher, a neighbour. Often this role is also taken by a sibling who is going through the same experience and can understand. She called this person a “helping witness”. And for the adult who begins to see their own story, she spoke of the “enlightened witness”: someone who knows, who does not minimise or justify, and who stays beside the person as they face their truth, making that process a little easier.

The therapeutic relationship can become such a space. The therapist may become a companion on a path that once had to be walked alone, supporting the client by becoming the enlightened witness they did not have back then.

Perhaps, in the end, the question is not whether our parents loved us or not. Many of them loved us in the only way they knew how — and that way hurt us.

Perhaps the question is whether, today, we can allow the child we once were to say what they could not say then, and to feel what there was no room to feel then.

And to hear, at last, that what happened to them was not their fault.

References

  • Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and loss: Vol. 1. Attachment. Basic Books.
  • Fairbairn, W. R. D. (1943). The repression and the return of bad objects (with special reference to the “war neuroses”). British Journal of Medical Psychology, 19(3–4), 327–341.
  • Freyd, J. J. (1996). Betrayal trauma: The logic of forgetting childhood abuse. Harvard University Press.
  • Freyd, J. J., & Birrell, P. J. (2013). Blind to betrayal: Why we fool ourselves we aren’t being fooled. John Wiley & Sons.
  • Herman, J. L. (1992). Trauma and recovery. Basic Books.
  • Main, M., & Hesse, E. (1990). Parents’ unresolved traumatic experiences are related to infant disorganized attachment status: Is frightened and/or frightening parental behavior the linking mechanism? In M. T. Greenberg, D. Cicchetti, & E. M. Cummings (Eds.), Attachment in the preschool years (pp. 161–182). University of Chicago Press.
  • Miller, A. (1979/1981). The drama of the gifted child (original: Das Drama des begabten Kindes). Basic Books.
  • Miller, A. (1983). For your own good: Hidden cruelty in child-rearing and the roots of violence (original: Am Anfang war Erziehung, 1980). Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
  • Miller, A. (1990). Banished knowledge: Facing childhood injuries (original: Das verbannte Wissen, 1988). Doubleday.
  • Miller, A. (2005). The body never lies: The lingering effects of cruel parenting (original: Die Revolte des Körpers, 2004). W. W. Norton.
  • Yalom, I. D. (1980). Existential psychotherapy. Basic Books.