Shame is one of the least discussed emotions, precisely because its nature is to hide. Whatever makes us feel ashamed, we keep inside — and as long as we do, the shame survives. Perhaps this is why so many people come to psychotherapy talking about anxiety, difficult relationships, depression or struggles with how they see themselves, and only much later, once the relationship feels safe enough, are they able to look at the deeper feelings that usually lie behind their symptoms.

Shame or guilt?

The two words are often used as if they meant the same thing, but they describe two different experiences. When we feel guilt, our attention goes to something we did: “I said or did something harsh and I hurt someone.” There is an action, and there is a way forward: we can apologise, make amends, do something differently next time. When we feel shame, the focus shifts from the action to the self: “I am worthless.” And for this “I am”, we often cannot easily find a way to make amends.

The psychoanalyst Helen Block Lewis drew this distinction with particular clarity, describing shame as an experience in which the whole self becomes the object of negative evaluation, while in guilt the evaluation focuses more on a specific act (Lewis, 1971). This is why shame is harder to manage: it tells us that something within us is flawed. “There’s something wrong with me” is a phrase heard very often in therapy sessions.

Healthy shame and toxic shame

Not every experience of shame is pathological. Shame is a natural human emotion, linked to an awareness of how we present ourselves and how others evaluate us. The problem is not that we feel shame, but when it stops being about a particular situation and becomes a constant way of experiencing ourselves.

Toxic shame is something else. It is not about a particular relationship, a failure, or a moment we would like to forget; it has settled at the core of the self and keeps whispering the same sentence: I am not enough, I am not worthy, and that is why I am not loved, why I am rejected or hurt. It involves a sense that something is wrong with us as people — that we do not manage well enough, that we are not worthy or capable enough to be loved or to succeed. We often hear this “something is wrong with me” from people who carry wounds from their relationships with their parents. Because this very feeling was created early in life, within our first relationships.

Shame is deeply relational.

As we grow up, we learn who we are by internalising the way the significant adults in our lives look at us and interact with us — parents, other relatives, teachers and so on.

“If they see me this way, that must be who I am.”

A child does not yet have a stable, independent definition and sense of self. When they are frightened, they look to their parent to understand whether there is real danger. When they cry, they wait for a response that will show them what their feeling means. When they are happy, they look in the other person’s face for confirmation that their joy is valid and welcome.

Our self-perception and sense of self, in other words, are co-created through thousands of such small interpersonal interactions and experiences.

I am someone worth listening to, caring for, reassuring.
I am someone who can make mistakes and still be loved.
My feelings have room; they are recognised and allowed to exist. My feelings are respected and acknowledged, so I am seen.

Or, on the contrary:

I am too much.
I am difficult.
I shouldn’t need anything.
When I get angry, people move away.
When I cry, I’m a nuisance.
When I have needs, I’m a burden.
When I fail, I disappoint.
To be loved, I have to be different.

Research has found associations between internalised shame and early experiences of indifference, abandonment and rejection (Claesson & Sohlberg, 2002). More recent reviews and meta-analyses also point to a significant relationship between insecure attachment patterns and shame (Jiang et al., 2026). This does not mean that everyone who grew up with a critical parent will necessarily develop intense shame. Nor does it mean that we can explain a person’s entire psychology solely through their childhood. It does mean, however, that the relationships we grow up in provide much of the material from which the image we have of ourselves is built.

When the child becomes “the problem”

Imagine a child who comes home from school upset.

“I don’t want to go back. The other kids push me away, they make fun of me and they don’t want to be friends with me.”

A parent might reply:

“Don’t be so sensitive.”

The child does not only learn that this particular difficulty is not very important.

They may begin to learn something much deeper:

“My sensitivity is a problem. This shouldn’t bother me.”

Or to a child who gets angry:

“You’re so ungrateful when you act like that.”

Perhaps they will grow up not only with the memory that their anger was difficult for others, but with the sense that:

“When I express something that bothers me, I become ungrateful.”

Or to a child who fails a test:

“How can you not manage this?”

When emotional messages like these are repeated and conveyed to a child systematically, they can turn into an inner voice.

And at some point, there no longer needs to be an adult in front of us telling us that we are not enough.

We tell ourselves.

Because the relationship may have become our inner voice.

The voice with which we speak to ourselves was often the way others spoke to us, at a time when we were learning who we were and who we could become.

A woman may have grown up with a mother who constantly commented on her appearance — very often, on her body. Years later, nobody needs to tell her that she is not beautiful. She stands in front of the mirror and tells herself.

A man may have grown up with a father who treated every failure as proof of incompetence. As an adult, he may make a small mistake at work and suddenly feel that he is worth nothing.

In this way, the old childhood relationship may continue within new, adult relationships.

Shame can change the way we love

When the other person pulls back a little:

“They must have realised who I really am.”

And so a vicious circle is created.

The need for love becomes very intense, because love seems to confirm the worth of the self. At the same time, however, intimacy itself may provoke fear, because it brings with it the possibility of revealing what a person feels they truly are.

“If they get to know me well enough, they’ll leave.”

This is one of the most painful forms of shame.

Shame does not say, “I feel bad about the way I was treated.”

It says:

“It’s your fault they treated you that way. If you were different, they would have treated you better.”

Because if the other person sees who we really are, they might reject us.

So someone may hide their sadness from their partner.

Not say that they were frightened.

Not ask for connection.

Not admit that they were hurt.

Pretend that they don’t care.

Become excessively self-sufficient.

Or, on the contrary, constantly try to please others, read their moods and anticipate their needs.

Beneath many of these behaviours, the same anguish may lie:

“If they see me as I really am, perhaps they’ll stop loving me.”

In cases of deeper relational trauma, shame may also become linked with disconnection, the suppression of feeling and the avoidance of contact — paradoxically functioning as a way of protecting ourselves from unbearable relational experiences (Benau, 2018).

We are not saying that “it’s all down to childhood”

It is important here to avoid an oversimplified narrative. Not every sense of worthlessness is created by the relationship with our parents. Shame is influenced by temperament, experiences with peers, school, rejection, bullying, romantic relationships, social and cultural expectations, and other experiences.

Sometimes it is enough for a child to have felt, again and again, that their self and their feelings do not easily fit within their relationships.

The healing of shame is, to a large extent, a relational experience

If a significant part of our shame was shaped within relationships, it will not change simply by reassuring ourselves that we are enough and worthy of love. Shame is not just a thought.

It is a deeply organised expectation and sense of how others see us.

This is why the therapeutic relationship can become important. Not because the therapist “corrects” the image we have of ourselves, but because a space of acceptance and safety is created, in which we can gradually begin to exist differently.

To express the things we feel ashamed of, the things others usually judge us for.

To show anger, and for the relationship not to be destroyed.

To say “I need” and not be considered a burden, or feel judged.

To make a mistake and not feel that we lose our worth.

To show a side of ourselves that we consider unwanted, and to meet not aversion or rejection, but interest and understanding.

Shame then begins to encounter a different experience:

“It is possible to be seen and accepted.”

And, little by little, we may be able to tolerate being imperfect, vulnerable, angry, frightened, needy, uncertain, with needs and limits — and, despite all of this, worthy of connection, acceptance and love.

References

  • Benau, K. (2018). Pride in the psychotherapy of relational trauma: Conceptualization and treatment considerations. European Journal of Trauma & Dissociation, 2(3), 131–146.
  • Claesson, K., & Sohlberg, S. (2002). Internalized shame and early interactions characterized by indifference, abandonment and rejection: Replicated findings. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 9, 277–284.
  • Jiang, X., Zhang, Y., Wu, C., Liu, D., & Zhang, J. (2026). The relationship between insecure attachment and shame: A meta-analysis. Personality and Individual Differences, 251, 113585. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2025.113585
  • Lewis, H. B. (1971). Shame and guilt in neurosis. International Universities Press.
  • Yontef, G. (1996). Shame and guilt in Gestalt therapy theory and practice. In R. Lee & G. Wheeler (Eds.), The voice of shame: Silence and connection in psychotherapy (pp. 351–380). Jossey-Bass.