Some children learn very early on to “read” the energy of the space around them.
“If it was quiet, I knew things were okay.”
“With my friends, I was always the one who made everyone laugh.”
“When I did well at school, they talked about me. When I didn’t, nobody said anything.”
If we ask someone why they find it hard to say “no” to a friend, why they freeze when their manager’s tone of voice changes, or why they feel empty as soon as an important piece of work is finished, they will rarely answer with a memory from the living room of their childhood or from the family dinner table. And yet, that is often where it begins.
Because at some point, very early on, a child needed to find answers to some very simple but very important questions.
What do I need to do to be safe?
How do I need to be for others to want me close?
What do I need to do to be loved and “seen”?
The child does not choose; the child adapts
Patricia Crittenden, a psychologist who trained with Mary Ainsworth — one of the most important figures in the study of parent–child interaction — developed the Dynamic-Maturational Model of Attachment and Adaptation (DMM).
In her model, attachment — the kind of bond between child and caregiver — is not simply a story about what that relationship was like in the past. It is a story about how we learned, deep within ourselves, to protect ourselves from danger, and what we need to do in order to be loved and accepted (Crittenden, 2005).
Danger, for a child, is not only violence or abuse. It may be a parent whose anger erupts unpredictably. A mother so tired or so sad that the child feels they have to look after her. The sense that love and care may be withdrawn if I am not a “good child”. Or the threat of being left out at break time — of being laughed at, of being humiliated in front of everyone.
Faced with these things, a child does not stop to consider what would be best for their mental health thirty years from now. They do whatever their child’s mind can conceive of as working best in that moment. Whatever keeps them close to those who care for them, whatever gives them a sense of safety and control, and so helps them survive emotionally and psychologically.
Crittenden calls these solutions self-protective strategies. And she insists on something that may change the whole way we look at our personality: these are not character flaws or inherited weaknesses. They are adaptations to a particular environment, under particular conditions and with particular people, shaped by the particular needs of the child.
Three scenes: home, the playground, the classroom
One way of thinking about these strategies is as a triangle, as the behavioural analyst Chase Hughes has described it in an interview. The three sides of this triangle correspond to three very common settings of childhood, and to how the child existed within each of them.
The triangle reflects something we also find in Crittenden’s thinking: that a child’s world is not only about home, but also about the environments in which they are socialised.
At home, the question the child has to answer is about safety. One child may learn to read, with remarkable accuracy, how the door was closed, how the keys sounded, how an adult is moving around the room. Another may learn to become small, quiet, almost invisible. A third may learn that they cannot expect help from anyone and must manage on their own.
In the school years, roughly from five to twelve, the child steps outside the family and meets new people (Crittenden, Kozlowska & Landini, 2010). For part of the day, teachers take on something of the protection and comfort that, until then, only the child’s caregivers at home had provided.
This is why teachers so often appear as significant figures when people talk about their past. A teacher who treats a child harshly may leave a lasting mark, while another who responds with empathy and support may become a protective figure for that child.
This is also where friends appear. A best friend asks for exclusivity and closeness, while the wider group asks us to resemble it and be loyal to it. Making room for both is not easy, and children who do not manage to form a close friendship tend to be more exposed to isolation and bullying. Exclusion, mockery and shame in front of others thus become new forms of danger, just as real for a child as any threats or anxieties that may exist at home.
In the playground, then, and in spaces shared with other children, the question is: how can I belong? This is where one child becomes the joker of the group; another becomes the chameleon who tries to fit in through particular clothes, games and preferences depending on who is in front of them; another becomes the child who always helps, always gives, always says “yes”; and another becomes the one who shrinks their presence so much that they become harmless through their invisibility.
Through Crittenden’s lens, we can see these roles as self-protective strategies: ways of belonging to the group without getting hurt. A child may, for example, respond with compulsive compliance to a teacher who does not understand them.
In the classroom, and in the eyes of adults, the question is about recognition. Some children learn that they are seen when they succeed; others when they are quiet and obedient; others only when they stand out and excel.
The three sides are rarely independent of one another. The child who was invisible at home may have become the most obedient child in class. The child who looked after their mother may have become the one who looked after all their friends as well. The same solution is often carried from one scene to another, because the child received the message: this is how I survive, this is how I stay safe.
But, as with many adaptive mechanisms of childhood, there comes a point in adult life when these strategies cost us more than they give us — because we have changed, while our ways of surviving have not changed with us.
What I predict and what I feel
Crittenden describes two ways in which a child tries to make sense of the world. The first is cognitive information: children observe what follows what, what is rewarded and what is punished. The second is affective information: fear, anger, the need for comfort, the longing for closeness.
When the environment is predictable but feelings are not accepted, the child learns to rely on the first and to hide the second. They do what they know their environment will reward, and set aside whatever feelings have no room to exist.
As the child grows, this may take more intense forms, such as those Crittenden calls compulsive caregiving — when a child protects themselves by looking after a parent who is vulnerable (for example, where there is substance use, bereavement or mental health difficulties) — or compulsive compliance, when the child learns to anticipate the wishes of an adult they are afraid of.
Here we might recognise the “good child”, the child who had to cope, the child who made sure they were useful.
When the environment is unpredictable — when care sometimes comes and sometimes does not, without the child being able to understand what this depends on — the child learns to rely on feeling. They may amplify their fear or their anger in order to keep the adults’ attention on them. Here we might recognise the child who was constantly on alert, or the child who needed to stand out in order to feel that they existed.
Only when a child can trust both — what they understand and what they feel — can relationships and communication become more open, direct and mutual.
None of the above are absolute descriptions of what happened or of its consequences. Most people will recognise pieces of themselves on different sides. It is more of a map, to help us understand where and how something that troubles us today may have begun.
“Every strategy is good for some problem”
In an interview, Crittenden puts it very simply: every strategy is the right one for some problem, but no strategy is the best one for every problem.
The child who read faces and voices was not “anxious”. They were a child protecting themselves in a home where the atmosphere could change without warning. Research suggests that children who grow up in threatening environments recognise anger in other people’s faces faster, and on the basis of less information, than other children do (Pollak & Sinha, 2002). It is a capacity born out of the need to survive.
The difficulty is that a strategy often keeps operating even when the danger is no longer there. The adult who was once the child who had to be watchful may continue to scan every message, every look, every silence from a partner or a manager, becoming exhausted or anxious as though their survival still depended on someone else — without consciously realising it.
The woman who was once the “good girl” may keep swallowing her anger at work, and then turn it on herself: Why didn’t I say anything? What is wrong with me?
And beneath these thoughts there is often something deeper than simple self-criticism. There is a sense that our worth is always under examination and evaluation. That if I stop performing, helping, making others laugh, it will become clear that I am not worth anything.
Research on parental conditional regard describes precisely this: when love and warmth depend on whether a child performs or complies, the child may achieve a great deal, but their sense of self-worth becomes fragile and tends to be accompanied by guilt, shame and inner pressure (Assor, Roth & Deci, 2004).
What once saved us may now be keeping us away from what we need.
These strategies grow up with us
The word “maturational” in the name of the model is no accident. For Crittenden, strategies are not static traits sealed in infancy. They change as the child grows, as the brain matures, and as the relationships and dangers around them change.
Some more complex forms, such as compulsive caregiving or compliance, only become possible once the child has enough capacity to understand what the other person wants and to conceal what they themselves feel (Crittenden, 2005).
This has two sides. On the one hand, a strategy can become more and more refined over the years — so refined that we no longer see it as a strategy, but as “our personality”. That’s just how I am. I was always the one who could handle everything, the strong one. I was always the one who helps.
On the other hand, maturation also brings something the child did not have: the capacity to reflect on what we are doing. To see the pattern, to understand where it came from, to feel the emotion it kept hidden — and so to differentiate ourselves in the present, through awareness of where we now stand.
Crittenden calls this reflective integration: the moment when we can listen to both the logic and the feeling of our story, without having to hide one in order to hold on to the other.
In many of these situations, if we look closely, we will see a child who is still trying to protect themselves in the ways they once did.
I am reminded of a client who had learned to make her needs smaller in order to be the easy, accommodating child. In the present, she was very good at caring for others: she remembered all the small details about them and tried to help them and make things easier for them. When it came to herself, however, she might feel ashamed to ask for something she needed — as if she were a shy little girl who knew very well how to look after others in a grown-up way, but who related to herself almost as an infant.
And Crittenden writes something that offers hope: strategies can change when they no longer fit the context (Crittenden, 2005). We do not need to fight them. We need to be able to see that the context has changed, and that we are no longer the small children we once were.
When the old strategy meets new relationships
Childhood strategies do not stay at home, in the playground or in the classroom. They follow us into every relationship in which something resembles, even slightly, the old danger.
And we often experience them first in the body: in the stomach that tightens just before we say “no” — and then we say “yes”; in the smile that appears automatically when the atmosphere grows heavy and we feel awkward; in the flood of thoughts that takes over when someone does not reply to a message.
There is one relationship, however, in which our strategies may become visible more clearly than anywhere else: our relationship with our own children. Crittenden devoted an entire book to this, Raising Parents.
A parent who learned as a child to hide their sadness may find it hard to bear their child’s crying. A parent who learned that they were only worth something when they performed may, without meaning to, look at the grades first and at the face second.
For Crittenden, parents who struggle are not a different kind of people from the rest of us. Like all of us, they carry ways of being that once protected them (Crittenden, 2016).
In therapy, Crittenden describes the therapist as a transitional attachment figure: a person with whom we can try out, safely, something that was once dangerous.
To be angry and to see that the relationship survives. To tolerate not being “perfect”, not knowing, pausing, struggling — and to find that acceptance and safety are not lost. And gradually, to carry this experience into our other relationships.
In The Gift of Therapy, Irvin Yalom prefers to think of the therapist and the person who comes to therapy as fellow travellers. Not as someone who knows and someone who needs to be corrected, but as two people, each carrying their own story and their own solutions.
Perhaps this is why such a relationship can become safe in a way that things once were not: because I do not need to be a certain way — the good child, the funny one, the strong one — for the other person to stay with me.
What is the danger today?
For Crittenden, there are no “good” and “bad” strategies. There are strategies that fit, or do not fit, the situation we are living in now.
We do not need to erase our old strategies.
The ability to read others, humour, generosity, devotion, endurance — these are strengths we have carried since then. The aim is to develop a wider repertoire, so that we can choose according to what best serves us in what is happening in front of us (Crittenden, 2005).
To be able to make jokes without feeling the pressure that it is our responsibility to change the energy in the room, or using humour as a defence against our own difficulty. To help others, while also setting boundaries and taking care of ourselves. To make an effort, while also being able to rest without guilt.
So perhaps it may help, the next time the old script starts running automatically, to pause for a moment and ask:
What is this reaction trying to protect me from?
Is that danger here, in this relationship, today?
Perhaps, in the end, the question is not “What is wrong with me?” but “What do I need now, in this relationship, in order to feel safe, to belong and to be seen?”
References
- Assor, A., Roth, G., & Deci, E. L. (2004). The emotional costs of parents’ conditional regard: A self-determination theory analysis. Journal of Personality, 72(1), 47–88.
- Crittenden, P. M. (2005). Attachment theory, psychopathology, and psychotherapy: The dynamic-maturational approach. Psicoterapia, 30, 171–182.
- Crittenden, P. M. (2016). Raising parents: Attachment, representation, and treatment (2nd ed.). Routledge.
- Crittenden, P. M., Kozlowska, K., & Landini, A. (2010). Assessing attachment in school-age children. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 15(2), 185–208.
- Crittenden, P. M., & Landini, A. (2011). Assessing adult attachment: A dynamic-maturational approach to discourse analysis. W. W. Norton.
- Pollak, S. D., & Sinha, P. (2002). Effects of early experience on children’s recognition of facial displays of emotion. Developmental Psychology, 38(5), 784–791.
- Yalom, I. D. (2002). The gift of therapy: An open letter to a new generation of therapists and their patients. HarperCollins.



