Shame often hides behind behaviours that seem, on the surface, to be unrelated. The psychiatrist Donald Nathanson observed that when this feeling becomes unbearable, people tend to respond in four main ways, which he called the “compass of shame” (Nathanson, 1992):
The first is through self-criticism — by becoming the first to blame and belittle ourselves, before anyone else can. This form of attack on the self, beyond negative thoughts about ourselves, may also be accompanied by behaviours such as self-harm and other ways of treating ourselves harshly or abusively. It is very often accompanied by thoughts such as “No one would want me” or “Why would anyone treat me well?”
The second involves withdrawal. When feelings of shame are activated, we may have the urge to disappear — from our friends, from our relationship, from our own life. Isolation looks like protection, but it is the ground in which shame takes root more deeply. It is common for people, after contact with parents or others who have triggered feelings of shame, to hide away in their safe space until they feel able to face the world again.
The third involves avoidance: anything that can take us away from feeling our emotions, when it is done to excess — work, screens, alcohol, food, video games, gambling or social media, all of which can function as ways of avoiding or distancing ourselves from difficult feelings.
And finally, there is the attempt to relieve our shame by verbally attacking the other person. When shame is unbearable, attacking the other can serve as a way of moving away from our own vulnerable experience. Sometimes the tendency to project our feelings onto others — belittling or insulting them so that we can feel superior — is a cover that helps us avoid coming into contact with our own difficult feelings.
For example, what may look like anger is sometimes the expression of a deeper shame. Someone receives a comment from their partner and, instead of recognising “I feel exposed now that you’ve seen a side of me I consider inadequate”, they respond aggressively: “Who do you think you are to criticise me?” Attacking the other person may offer temporary protection from the far more vulnerable experience of “I’m not enough — they’ve seen my vulnerability.”
When shame looks like depression
Shame restricts our aliveness and spontaneity. It reduces our interest, our joy, our willingness to explore the world — and what remains can look very much like depression: tiredness, withdrawal, or a feeling that nothing has meaning.
A large meta-analysis of 108 studies with more than 22,000 participants found that shame is significantly more strongly associated with depressive symptoms than guilt is (Kim, Thibodeau & Jorgensen, 2011).
This does not mean that all depression is really shame, nor that anyone can diagnose themselves from an article. But it does suggest something useful: when sadness does not lift, it may be worth asking whether, beneath it, there is something that has never been said to anyone — something to do with feelings and thoughts about ourselves. Beneath depression, there are often intense feelings of shame.
For example, someone may say “I don’t want to leave the house”, but if we go one step deeper, something qualitatively different may emerge: “I don’t want them to see me like this.” It is not only a lack of energy that keeps us hidden. It is also the belief that if others see what we are really like, they will be disappointed, reject us, or realise that we are not enough.
The broken bridge: shame as a break in contact
The psychologist Gershen Kaufman described shame as the breaking of the “interpersonal bridge”: the connection with a significant person that allows us to grow up feeling seen, wanted and accepted (Kaufman, 1974). Nothing dramatic is needed for this bridge to crack. It may be enough for a parent’s gaze to keep drifting away at the very moment the child needs to be acknowledged, or for a “Don’t be such a baby” to come where the child was expecting enthusiasm. The child does not conclude, “My parent is tired or not in the mood right now.” The child concludes, “Something is wrong with me.”
In Gestalt psychotherapy we say that shame interrupts the cycle of contact at the most vulnerable point of meeting another person: precisely at the moment we reach out with our gaze or our hand and turn towards them. The impulse towards contact turns back on itself. Instead of saying “I need you”, we tell ourselves, “Don’t be so demanding, don’t have so many needs.” We may, for example, want to ask our partner for more tenderness.
Before we have even expressed it, however, we hear inside: “Don’t be needy”, “Don’t pressure him”, “Don’t come across as too much.” The need does not disappear; it simply stops before it reaches the other person. And so the relationship is deprived of exactly the information that could have created more closeness. Shame, then, is not simply an unpleasant feeling; it is a way of losing our connection with the other person — and, along with it, a part of ourselves (Yontef, 1996).
Winnicott described the “false self” as an adapted form of the self that may develop when a person learns to respond more to the demands of their environment than to their own spontaneous needs. These are the personas we create in order to feel more acceptable: the person who functions flawlessly, who never bothers anyone, never exposes themselves; who looks after everyone but feels guilty when they need care; who never asks for anything, who is always available; who makes jokes when they are hurt; who says “I don’t mind” and then thinks about it for days.
Then a painful question may arise: if others love this constructed version of me, could they ever love who I really am? And this is exactly where therapy cannot be only a conversation about shame. Shame was created within a relationship, and it needs a safe relationship in order to come into the open and soften: someone who listens to what we consider the worst part of ourselves, and stays with interest.
In psychotherapy we often hear the words, “I’ve never told anyone this. I don’t feel comfortable sharing it with others — they won’t understand.” In Gestalt we say that change does not happen when we try to become someone else (Beisser, 1970) — the person we were taught we should be, the person we would like to be, or the person others see — but when we finally stand where we really are, and are met there.
Shame cannot be dealt with through logical arguments. Some practices, however, may help:
- Name it. “I feel ashamed.” This phrase alone creates a little distance from the feeling. When we name something, we can see it more clearly and create room for something else to exist as well.
- Tell another person. Shame feeds on secrecy. The antidote to shame is not only disclosure, but the experience that may follow it: “I said something about myself that I was afraid would make me less lovable — and the other person didn’t pull away.” These small experiences can gradually create a different relationship with ourselves and with others.
- Separate the action from the identity. “I did something that disappointed me” is not the same as “I am a bad person.” The first sentence leaves room for responsibility and repair; the second leaves room only for punishment.
- Return to the body. Shame usually has a strong physical dimension: we lower our gaze, feel a heaviness in the chest, feel that our voice will not come out. We can become aware of our breathing, ground ourselves, and send our body signals of safety through small movements that remind it that, right now, it is not under threat.
In psychotherapy we do not “fight” shame; we ask what it is trying to protect, and how it learned to do so. Very often we discover that it was once the only way a child could find to hold on to the relationship with the people they depended on.
Shame is often not only about something that happened. It is also about something we fear would change the way others see us if they found out. This is why there can be an entire “secret life” around shame: things we do not say, needs we hide, parts of ourselves we censor, and behaviours we try to explain without ever touching what we fear they really mean about us.
When to seek help
We do not need to have a “serious enough” secret in order to deserve support. If self-criticism has become our constant inner companion; if we systematically avoid situations in which we might feel exposed; if there is something we have never told anyone and have carried for years — that, in itself, is enough. We do not need to wait until shame becomes unbearable before sharing it. We can begin from the very place we have not dared to speak about with anyone: “This is something I’m ashamed to show you.”
References
- Beisser, A. (1970). The paradoxical theory of change. In J. Fagan & I. L. Shepherd (Eds.), Gestalt therapy now: Theory, techniques, applications (pp. 77–80). Harper & Row.
- Kaufman, G. (1974). The meaning of shame: Toward a self-affirming identity. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 21(6), 568–574. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0037251
- Kim, S., Thibodeau, R., & Jorgensen, R. S. (2011). Shame, guilt, and depressive symptoms: A meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 137(1), 68–96. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021466
- Nathanson, D. L. (1992). Shame and pride: Affect, sex, and the birth of the self. W. W. Norton.
- Winnicott, D. W. (1960). Ego distortion in terms of true and false self. In The maturational processes and the facilitating environment: Studies in the theory of emotional development (pp. 140–152). The Hogarth Press.
- Yontef, G. M. (1996). Shame and guilt in Gestalt therapy theory and practice. In R. G. Lee & G. Wheeler (Eds.), The voice of shame: Silence and connection in psychotherapy (pp. 351–380). Jossey-Bass.



